Corresponding author: Oleg L. Nikanorov ( nikanorov@okbm.nnov.ru ) Academic editor: Boris Balakin
© 2021 Denis V. Didenko, Dmitry Ye. Baluyev, Oleg L. Nikanorov, Sergey A. Rogozhkin, Sergey F. Shepelev, Andrey A. Aksenov, Maksim N. Zhestkov, Aleksandr Ye. Shchelyaev.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Didenko DV, Baluyev DYe, Nikanorov OL, Rogozhkin SA, Shepelev SF, Aksenov AA, Zhestkov MN, Shchelyaev AYe (2021) Development of a methodological approach for the computational investigation of the coolant flow in the process of the sodium cooled reactor cooldown. Nuclear Energy and Technology 7(1): 6166. https://doi.org/10.3897/nucet.7.65442

A methodological approach has been developed for the computational investigation of the thermalhydraulic processes taking place in a sodium cooled fast neutron reactor based on a Russian computational fluid dynamics code, FlowVision. The approach takes into account the integral layout of the reactor primary circuit equipment and the peculiarities of heat exchange in the liquid metal coolant, and makes it possible to model, using welldefined simplifications, the heat and mass exchange in the process of the coolant flowing through the reactor core, and the reactor heatexchange equipment. Specifically, the methodological approach can be used for justification of safety during the reactor cooldown, as well as for other computational studies which require simulation of the integral reactor core and heatexchange equipment.
The paper presents a brief overview of the methodological approaches developed earlier to study the liquid metal cooled reactor cooldown processes. General principles of these approaches, as well as their advantages and drawbacks have been identified.
A threedimensional computational model of an advanced reactor has been developed, including one heatexchange loop (a fourth part of the reactor). It has been demonstrated that the FlowVision gap model can be applied to model the space between the reactor core fuel assemblies (interwrapper space), and a porous skeleton model can be used to model the reactor’s heatexchange equipment. It has been shown that the developed methodological approach is applicable to solving problems of the coolant flow in different operating modes of liquid metal cooled reactor facilities.
Liquid metal cooled reactor, integral layout, methodological approach, CFD, FlowVision, reactor core, LMS, reactor cooldown, interwrapper space
The integral layout of a sodium cooled fast neutron reactor (BN), in which all of the primary circuit’s key components are installed inside of the reactor vessel, and the specific conditions of heat exchange in liquid metals, which make them different from the rest of the coolant types used in reactors, require dedicated methodological approaches to be developed to model processes of heat and mass exchange in current domestic computational fluid dynamics (CFD) codes. The developed methodological approaches are used for all kinds of computational studies into the thermalhydraulic processes taking place in sodium cooled fast neutron reactor facilities (BN). The results of such studies are used, e.g., to justify the BNtype reactor cooldown systems.
Major difficulties arising in a computational investigation of thermalhydraulic processes are connected with simulation of the reactor core and heatexchange equipment. The structural complexity of fuel assemblies (FA), as well as of intermediate (IHX) and autonomous heat exchangers (AHX), explained by a large number of components these comprise, require development of a methodological approach which would make it possible to calculate with an acceptable accuracy, using welldefined simplifications and dedicated models, the thermalhydraulic processes taking place in BN reactor facilities.
At the present time, one of the possible options under consideration for cooling down a sodium cooled fast neutron reactor facility (BN) in modes, which require decay heat removal, is the reactor cooldown through the space between the reactor core FAs referred to as the interwrapper space (Fig.
A number of research papers have been published for the past decade which deal with the computational analysis of the liquid metal cooled reactor cooldown using CFD codes. In (
The most sophisticated numerical model of the reactor core is presented in a report by the Argonne National Laboratory (
Studies have been underway in this country to simulate fuel assemblies and the reactor as the whole. In (
The cooldown of the PFBR reactor, India, via the core’s interwrapper space was calculated using the ANSYSCFX and STARCD commercial codes (
In 2015, the STARCD code was used to calculate the coolant flow in the Korean innovative reactor KALIMER (Park JongPil et al. 2015). The simulation involved the following assumptions: the core and the heat exchangers were given using a porous body model, and no interwrapper space and FA geometry were simulated.
A number of general principles can be pointed out after considering the above methodological approaches; more specifically, the core and the heat exchangers were simulated using a porous body model, and the full FA geometry is substituted by a volume with equivalent thermophysical properties. It should be also noted that results were obtained in these studies using either domestic precision codes, which do not currently allow solving engineering analysis problems, or based on multipurpose foreign CFD codes using RANS/URANS turbulence models which are applied to solve an extensive class of problems. Insufficient attention is given in these codes to the peculiarities of heat transfer in sodiumbased liquid metal coolants, so a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code, FlowVision, was chosen to develop the methodological approach for the computational investigation of the coolant flow in the sodium cooled reactor cooldown process. The choice of the FlowVision code is explained by the LMS (Liquid Metal Sodium) model it implements to calculate turbulent heat transfer in sodium coolant, as well as by a porous body model which makes it possible to calculate heat transfer in heatexchange equipment. The LMS model used as part of FlowVision was verified using an extensive experimental framework (
A 3D computational model and a methodological approach were developed based on the FlowVision code to investigate the heat and mass transfer processes and to justify the BN reactor safety as related to the reactor cooldown through the interwrapper space.
The geometrical reactor model (Fig.
Typical dimensions of the structural components (FAs with the interwrapper space, AHX, IHX, RCP) are much smaller than the dimensions of the structure’s main part. The flow resolution in these leads to a major increase in the number of the calculation cells and to the need to use highcapacity computational resources for the calculation. To optimize the time and the computational resources spent, as well as to simulate correctly the sodium flow in the reactor components, a FlowVision gap model was used (
To simplify the reactor computational model, the core FAs were represented as hexagonal elements in which the coolant hydraulic resistance and heatup were simulated. The resistance is assumed to be uniformly distributed throughout the assembly height, and the power density concentrates within the fuel (active) portion (Fig.
The FA model represents a metal casing in the form of a hexagonal tube on which the conditions of conjugation with the sodium surrounding the assembly and with the sodium filling the FA are given. A porous skeleton, which simulates the fuel assemblies, is given inside of the FA.
The reactor core simulation took into account the hydraulic profiling (HP) areas, including eight HP areas in the installation region of the main (central) FAs, four HP areas in the side blanket assemblies, and areas with the reflector, biological shielding and spent FA assemblies. The HP areas are characterized by different power density and coolant flow rate values.
A model, consisting of three FA types with different power densities, (Fig.
The interwrapper space in this model is geometrically divided from the FA inner volume. To take into account the heat transfer from the sodium inside of the FAs to the sodium in the interwrapper space, all assembly jackets were grouped to form separate analytical subregions, conjugated with the flow path through heat exchange, in which the equation of heat conductivity in a solid body was calculated.
A mode was considered in which the coolant with the given flow rate entered the computational region and was distributed over the FA bundle and the interwrapper space. The coolant heated in the FA entered the cavity behind the core and moved through the computational region’s outflow boundary. The reference quantities were the FA pressure drop, the coolant flow rate through each FA, the coolant flow rate through the intewrapper space, and the FA bundle outlet coolant temperature values.
Simplified and detailed assembly models were calculated for two computational grids. The simplified computational grid (Fig.
The simplified and detailed grid calculations were compared with each other. The solution obtained for the detailed computational grid was taken as the reference. The comparison of the calculation results showed that the simplified grid results, obtained using the gap model, differed from the detailed grid results, obtained without the gap model, by not more than 7%, this indicating the rightfulness of using the adopted core calculation methodology with no detailed interwrapper space resolution.
A FlowVision porous skeleton model was used to take into account the heat transfer into the IHX and the AHX. The heat exchanger tube bundles were substituted for annular elements in which the presence of simultaneously two fluids (primary sodium and secondary sodium) was given in the form of continuous and dispersed (porous skeleton) phases. The dispersed phase represents a rigid skeleton which fills a particular share of the computational region and allows simulating the irregularity of the BN reactor secondary circuit temperature distribution. The heat exchange between the circuits was taken into account by defining the thermophysical and thermalhydraulic characteristics in the continuous and dispersed phases with the aid of user variables (
The porous skeleton model made it possible to evaluate the irregularity of temperature distribution in both circuits. This approach was considered using an axisymmetrical calculation of a sodium flow through the test heat exchanger as the example (Fig.
The system of equations for the mathematical heat exchanger model consists of several equations solved numerically by the FlowVision code (
–FV – DV(Vn_{v}),
where V is the fluid velocity, m/s; n_{v} is the unit vector in the velocity direction; and F [kg/m^{3}s] and D [kg/m^{4}] are the coefficients responsible respectively for the linear and velocity quadratic parts of the resistance force. These coefficients are determined either empirically or through detailed calculations of the fluid movement inside of the FAs. The porous skeleton model adds also the fluid displacement as a result of the skeleton being present in the fluidoccupied volume.
It was found as a result of the heat exchanger test calculation that the heat exchanger parameters determined by the code differ from the design parameters by not less than 1%.
A threedimensional coolant flow in a BN reactor in the rated power operation mode was calculated to test the developed methodological approach and the computational model.
The coolant flow and the heat exchange in the reactor flow area was described in FlowVision using an ideal liquid turbulent flow model with regard for coupled heat transfer. The RCP sections in the pressure pipeline region are taken as the computational model boundaries so that to define the coolant inlet and outlet conditions. The normal component of the coolant mass flow rate, the coolant temperature, and the initial flow turbulence level is given for the model inlet. A free exit condition was given for the computational region outlet with giving the zero static pressure value.
An irregular initial grid condensed towards the FA region was used. Additionally, the initial grid was locally refined (adapted) in the FA wall region for a more detailed simulation of the coolant flow. The number of the computational cells in the model was about 5.6 million. The small number of the computational cells for such class of problems is explained by the fact that one of the reactor’s four heatremoving loops was calculated and a gap model was used.
A comparison of the results, obtained by numerical simulation, with the design data has confirmed that the developed computational model gives a good agreement between the obtained results and the design. The deviation of the average coolant incore heatup value, obtained in the calculation, does not exceed 3% of the design value, and the error of the core average pressure drop value is not more than 7.4%. The main sodium coolant circulation line in the reactor rated operation mode has the RCP – pressure chamber – core – IHX – AHX direction. The maximum coolant temperature is at the core outlet.
A methodological approach has been developed for the computational investigation of the coolant flow in a reactor during cooldown via the interwrapper space using the FlowVision computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code.
The developed methodological approach and a reactor model were used to study computationally the rated mode of the coolant flow in the reactor in a threedimensional statement.
A comparison of the numerical simulation results with the design data has confirmed that the methodology to calculate the coolant flow in the reactor core’s interwrapper space, using the FlowVision gap model, gives a good agreement of the obtained results with the anticipated parameters. No need for resolving the gaps between the FAs using a detailed computational grid leads to a considerable economy of the computational resources and time required for the calculations.
Simulation of the AHX and IHX heat exchangers using a porous skeleton model makes it possible to calculate the temperature distribution for the EHRS primary and intermediate circuits with regard for the heat retention capability of structural materials.
The developed methodological approach allows solving, with the required accuracy, complex problems of the coolant flow in BNtype reactors both in normal operating conditions and during anticipated operational occurrences requiring the EHRS connection.