Research Article |
Corresponding author: Nataliia Vladilenovna Shchukina ( shchukina@nrer.ru ) Academic editor: Elena Sarapultseva
© 2025 Oleg Konstantinovich Vlasov, Irina Aleksandrovna Zvonova, Nataliia Vladilenovna Shchukina.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Vlasov OK, Zvonova IA, Shchukina NV (2025) Radioecological modelling of 131I activity dynamics in milk in the central part of Mazovia: reconstruction, verification, reliability assessments. Nuclear Energy and Technology 11(1): 13-23. https://doi.org/10.3897/nucet.11.138995
|
The work was aimed to the study the 137Cs and 131I transport dynamics along the trophic chain, from the atmosphere to soil, vegetation, dairy cattle, milk, and the human body. This was done with the use of the radioecological simulation model based on instrumental data from the “Warsaw” scenario of the International Atomic Energy Agency’s (IAEA) EMRAS project, which were collected after the Chernobyl nuclear accident. The created simulated radioecological model was used for reconstruction of the 131I radioactivity in dairy cattle milk in the Warsaw and Ostroleka areas located in the central part of Mazovia, where the cattle dairy milk radiometry was performed in April-May 1986. The aim of the study was to verify the radioecological model, to assess the reliability and uncertainty of the milk block of the computed model. It was found that the successive account of discrepancies between computed and reconstructed instrumental data of 131I radioactivity dynamics in green fodder on farms in Mazovia areas and the shortage of clean fodder stocks harvest lead to a successive improvement of the agreement between computed and instrumental data of 131I activity in the dairy milk. For all variants of accounting correction the ratio of computed data to instrumental data with recalculated 131I activities in the atmosphere of the Ostroleka Area is on average 2.5–3 times closer to their ideal value of 1 than in calculations with instrumental data for a cloud. The prognostic properties of the computational model at the stage of reconstruction of the specific 131I activity in milk, estimated as the ratio of computed data to instrumental data, can be estimated as 1.05±2.0; the values of these ratios for correction of thyroid radiation doses to the population due to the contaminated milk consumption are estimated as 1.3±2.5.
Chernobyl accident, IAEA EMRAS project, “Warsaw” scenario, dynamic agroradioecological model, dairy farms, weather conditions, supply of farms with clean fodder, specific activity of 131I in milk, verification and estimation of model uncertainties, inhalation and feed components of milk contamination, radiobiology, environmental health
This work is the sixth in a series of works by the authors (
In the “Warsaw” scenario, for the study objects: 29 localities, 27 dairy farms, 24 dairy counties and two dairy areas: Warsaw Area and Ostroleka Area, the following database of instrumental data for 1986 is presented:
The database created in previous studies (
The aim of the study is to verify and assess the uncertainties of reconstructing the dynamics of 131I specific activity in milk in dairy areas of Mazovia central part after the Chernobyl accident.
The dynamics studies of the 131I specific activity in milk at its sampling points for radiometry in the Mazovia Area are carried out using the cattle unit of the radioecological model (
The block is a software package for calculating the metabolism of 131I radionuclides in cattle organs by numerically solving a system of linear differential equations for a multi-chamber model (Fig.
Verification of the model and estimation of its uncertainties was carried out based on calculations of geometric means and standard deviations of the ratio of the calculated data to the instrumental data.
To demonstrate the capabilities of this block, a scenario calculation was performed with the input data presented in Table
parameter | Mazovia, Warsaw Area |
---|---|
fallout start time | 2.4 days |
grazing start time | 25 days |
cattle keeping mode | pasture |
Time of transfer to clean feed | 45 days |
milk yield | 11.6, l/day |
green fodder consumption | 50, kg/day |
An example of the dynamics of 131I activities in the organs and excretion channels of cattle in the central part of Mazovia with the input data of Table
It can be noted from the features in Fig.
The rapid decline in the 131I activity in all organs and channels of its excretion from the body firstly begins after the transfer of cattle to clean feed on the 45th day. In two days, the milk activity decreases by 5 times. The activity decrease rate in all organs remains constant in accordance with the iodine radioactive decay. The slow component of its excretion rate from the thyroid gland, for times longer than 50 days.
Studies of the 131I activities dynamics in milk was carried out using the radioecological database created in (
All calculations were performed using three variants of atmospheric parameters: direct calculation, homogeneous cloud, and heterogeneous precipitation.
Direct calculation: for all settlements in the region (the area where instrumental data on radionuclide activity dynamics in the atmosphere were collected), instrumental data on 137Cs and 13II activity dynamics and their phases of existence in the atmosphere are used. The meteorological data on precipitation at weather stations nearest to the settlements during the period of major precipitation as well as are used.
Homogeneous cloud – heterogeneous precipitation: Spatial uniformity of specific radionuclide volume activities in the atmosphere over the region – heterogeneous effective precipitation at settlements. The precipitation at settlements with constant intensity during major precipitation, reconstructed from instrumental 137Cs data in the atmosphere and precipitation densities at settlements.
Heterogeneous cloud – homogeneous precipitation: The heterogeneous cloud region includes all settlements within the area covered by the nearest weather station. For each locality in this region, data from this meteorological station regarding precipitation during the period of significant precipitation is used. The dynamics of specific radioactivity in the atmosphere above each location is normalized based on the precipitation intensity, expressed in terms of 137Cs density.
According to the “Warsaw” scenario, most private farms in the milk areas of Ostroleka Area suffered from a shortage of uncontaminated feed from last year’s harvest and the diet of milk cattle partially included freshly harvested contaminated green feed. Green fodder was included in the milk cattle diet only at half of farms on average for the period from 1.05.86 to 20.10.86.
The data on gross milk production, the forage lands structure, as well as data on 137Cs fallout densities and rains for the major fallout period calculated from weather station data are presented in scenario for Warsaw Area and Ostoleka Area.
This information, as well as the calculated data of the dependences on rains of cultivated pasture grass specific activity during the main fallout, given in (
, (1)
where
j is the calculation model: 1 – direct calculation, 2 – inhomogeneous cloud, 3 – homogeneous cloud;
– the farms fraction in the district that does not have stocks of clean feed in May 1986, it is assumed that it corresponds to the average proportion of contaminated feed in the diet of cattle in the dairy district,
– the radioactive fraction of milk produced in the milk county,
Rkj – average rains for the rains major period used in the j-th calculation model, mm;
Ikinh and Ikgrf – 131I specific activities integrals in milk due to inhalation and contaminated green feed, (kBq/kg)*day;
here
, (2)
, (3)
where
kClkj is the conversion coefficient of the 131I specific activity in the atmosphere for the j-th model;
kCl 0 j =2, I0inh and Q0grf,j were estimated using the direct calculation model for the Warszawa Observw Astr weather station with rains over the period of major fallout, 0.8 mm; respectively, equal to 1.72 , 14.4 (kBq/kg)*day and 696 (kBq/kg)*day; Rkj – rains in k – milk county, мм.
An example of the radioecological parameters calculation results for the Warszawski Zachodni milk county with the farms proportion without pure feed stocks by the date of the accident equal to 30% is shown in Table
Calculation model | kQcloud | R mm | q max grf kBq/kg | Imilkinh (kBq/kg)*day | Imilkgrf (kBq/kg)*day | δdiary / δmilk, % |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
direct calculation | 1.0 | 0.8 | 38 | 14.4 | 604 | 31.6 |
heterogeneous cloud | 3.9 | 0.8 | 140.6 | 56 | 2230 | 31.7 |
homogeneous cloud | 1.0 | 7.8 | 33.6 | 14.4 | 534 | 31.8 |
The data in Table
The results of calculations for other counties in which milk samples were taken for radiometry, shown in Table
Milk Area | milk county | fallout density 137Cs, kBq/m2 | rains, мм | δdiary / δmilk, % | Nизм | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
mean | min | max | Rmeteo | Rrec | ||||
Warsaw Area | Legionowski | 4.1 | 3 | 7 | 0 | 40.1 | 20/22 | 24 |
Minski | 4.5 | 4 | 5 | 0 | 40.2 | 30/32 | 4 | |
Nowodworski Mazowiecki | 3.8 | 2 | 6 | 0 | 30.2 | 50/51 | 5 | |
Warszawski | 4.5 | 3 | 6 | 0 | 40.7 | 15/17 | 28 | |
Warszawski Zachodni++ | 6.7 | 10.5 | 14 | 0 | 70.8 | 30/31 | 20 | |
Wolominski++ | 5.7 | 6 | 8 | 10 | 60 | 30/31 | 4 | |
Falenty Duze diary*++ | 0.8 | 20.5 | 0.0/2.0** | 8 | ||||
Ostroleka Area | Ostrolecki++ | 4.6 | 3 | 3.5 | 0 | 00.8 | 50/51 | 20+ |
Ostroleka | 4.6 | 3 | 3.5 | 0 | 0 | 0.0/2.0** | 20 | |
Piski | 3.8 | 20.5 | 6 | 0 | 00.3 | 40/40 | 8 | |
Przasnyski | 3.6 | 20.5 | 4 | 0 | 00.2 | 80/80 | 14 | |
Szczycienski | 4.3 | 20.5 | 5 | 0 | 00.5 | 90/90.2 | 3 | |
Zambrowski | 4.1 | 20.5 | 6.5 | 0 | 00.4 | 50/51 | 7 |
The values were used to adjust the calculated and reconstructed “instrumental” data of 131I specific activity in milk in the k-th milk county according to instrumental data for the district k0 to the ratios (4) and (5):
, (4)
, (5)
were
M and C indexes refer to instrumental and calculated data;
j-calculation model;
Qkj and Qkcor,j – direct and adjusted dependences of specific 131I activities in milk;
– calculated data of 131I activity dynamics in pasture grass;
Qkinh,j и Qkgrf,j – calculated dependences of inhalation and food components of milk contamination;
δkgrf – corrections for discrepancies of calculated and reconstructed “instrumental” data of specific 131I activities in pasture grass (
It should be noted here that the range of coefficient values
(6)
for recalculation of 131I activity in milk instrumental data Kkcor,j according to the direct calculation models of (j = 1) and homogeneous cloud (j = 3) is equal to (0.95–1.05), for heterogeneous cloud (j = 2) is equal to (0.5–1.7).
According to “Warsaw” scenario, the complete clean feed provision was only in the Ostroleka Area county of the Ostroleka Area and on the Falenty Duze diary farm of the Warsaw Area (Table
The most detailed, more than 10 times, multiple instrumental data on the 131I activity in milk dynamics in the Ostroleka Area counties were obtained for the Ostroleka diary farm, Przasnyski diary, in the Warsaw Area for the Warsaw town diary farm, Legionowski county and Falenty Duze diary farm (Fig.
Note the significant irregularity of the instrumental data for all districts in the all area near their maximum values and the apparent inconsistency between the Fig.
Firstly, the instrumental data in Fig.
Secondly, the 131I milk activity at the Falenty Daze farm at the time of the end of the fallout main was 10 times less than in the Ostroleka Area milk county.
This cartographic data is more consistent with the form of instrumental data on the 131I milk activity dynamics for this district, which completely coincide with the form of the Przasnyski district data in Fig.
According to the cartographic data of the “Warsaw” scenario (Fig.
Dynamics of milk 131I specific activity in the Legionowski county of the Warsaw Area and Falenty Duze farm: a) calculation without corrections; b) calculation which was carried out considering the discrepancies of the calculated and reconstructed “instrumental” green feed 131I activities; c) calculation was performed taking into account the share of pure green feed in the diet of cattle in dairy districts; d) calculation taking into account adjustments for pollution and pure green feed.
Considering these discrepancies in the Ostroleka area, an additional test was conducted for this area, in which the average proportion of contaminated feed was found to be 60%.
The 131I milk activities dynamics calculations were carried out for counties for which in the “Warsaw” scenario multiple instrumental data are available. At the first stage, for the Warsaw Area, the following calculations were carried out sequentially for all three variants of input data on rains and 137Cs and 131I activities in the atmosphere:
The results of calculations and instrumental data of milk 131I specific activities are presented for the Falenty Duze farm and Legionowski county without considering the corrections in Fig.
Reconstruction of the inhalation component of 131I intake into milk had performed on the example of instrumental data for Falenty Duze farm whose cattle diet included only pure feed from the last year harvest. It shows that the calculated data on the homogeneous cloud model are quite satisfactorily consistent with instrumental data both according to the statistics of their relations and their form reflecting the details of dynamics of 131I volumetric activities in the atmosphere.
The data in Fig.
The dynamics of the 131I specific milk activity in the Ostroleka county studies were carried out, as for the WarsawArea, using three calculation models and in two variants of 137Cs and 131I atmosphere volumetric activity dynamics:
Instrumental and calculated time dependences of milk specific 131I activities in not taking and taking into account adjustments for contamination and the pure feed part are presented in Figs
Milk specific 131I activity in the county Ostroleka: a) calculation without corrections, cloud – direct data; b) calculation without taking into account amendments, cloud – recalculated data; c) calculation taking into account corrections for contamination and the share of clean feed, cloud – direct data; d) calculation taking into account corrections for contamination and the share of clean feed, cloud – recalculated data.
In (
This is confirmed by a better consistency of the calculated and instrumental data of 131I activities in milk in the counties of the Ostroleka Area than in the variant with their direct instrumental data.
Note that the instrumental data for the Przasnyski in Fig.
The analysis of the calculated and instrumental data comparison showed that the calculated data for Warsaw Area reproduce the instrumental data better after 30 days than for Osrtoleka Area, and worse for times less than 20 days. There is an almost completely satisfactory consistency of the calculated and instrumental data in the range of 20–30 days for both variants.
The improvement in the convergence of calculated and instrumental data with sequential accounting of corrections is characteristic both for all districts of both districts, and for these milk areas in whole (Fig.
Note the main features of the residual errors of the calculated and instrumental data in Fig.
The standard geometric mean deviations of the residuals in the form of minimum/average/maximum values respectively are equal 1.4/1.8/2.4 for the Ostroleka area, and 1.6/2.1/2.5 for the Warsaw Area respectively.
Thus, the data in Fig.
From the physics of radionuclide transfer along the chain: vegetation-cattle organism-milk-human body, it follows that the maximum of activities radionuclides activities in the human body due to their consumption with milk and greens will be directly proportional to their maximum activities. Accordingly, the nutritional component of internal radiation of thyroid and the entire human body along the chain will also be directly proportional to these values. With this in mind, the discrepancy in the form of the ratio of calculated and instrumental data of the specific activities of radionuclides in milk and greens can be used to adjust the calculated data of the integral of their entry into the human body according to the following ratio:
Icor = Pgr ∙ ICgr ∙ ∆−1gr + Pmilk ∙ ICmilk ∙ ∆−1milk, (7)
where
Icor is the adjusted total integral of the entry of the activity of radionuclides with greens and milk into the human body, kBq;
Pgr and Pmilk are daily consumption of greens and milk, kg/day,
ICgr and ICmilk are calculated integrals of specific radionuclide activities in greens and milk, kBq/kg* day;
, , (8)
∆gr and ∆milk are discrepancies of calculated qdir and instrumental qinstr data of specific radionuclide activities in greensgr and in milkmilk in the scope of instrumental data maximum values ⊂max.
* – is measured in (
In general, it can be assumed that the calculated model prognostic properties estimated in the form of standard geometrics means values and standards deviations of the ratio of calculated instrumental milk activity data, can be estimated as 1.05±2.0. The values of these ratios for adjusting the estimates of doses of radiation to the human thyroid, as
∆gr = 0.75 ± 1.7, ∆milk = 1.3 ± 2.5.
The 131I milk activity dynamics in the Mazovia central area was reconstructed. The reliability and uncertainty of the dynamic radioecological model block are evaluated.
The validity of the recalculation of the atmospheric contamination parameters over the Ostroleka area from instrumental data in Warsaw city is confirmed by a better adjustment of the calculated and instrumental data on the dynamics of 131I activities in milk than in calculations without such recalculation.
The main numerical results of the work performed are as follows: